Book: Eclipse-Stephenie Meyer

[~ ♥ Mariska ♥ ~]

I like Eclipse much more, because in New Moon it was all about Jacob and how she is feeling aweful that Edward is gone and all I wanted was for Edward to come back! But I don't get that if you hate Jacob, you can like New Moon better! In New Moon it's all about Jacob and how she misses Edward, Jacob is such a bigger part in New Moon!

Are there any parts left in Eclipse that aren't your favorite???

My favorite chapter was the one at Edwards Room where he proposes at the end! I just loved that chapter so much! It was funny, romantic and it was so nice that edward gave in on Bella's condition! And the meadow scene at the end was cute too! And I loved how Rosalie and Jasper told their stories! I am so glad that we got to know those too! Especially because the other ones are told before! And I loved the part where Jacob and Edward were talking, that was nice too! I just loved almost every part! Except for the part where she broke her hand and asked Jacob to kiss her!!

But if Eclipse is your number 3, does that mean that Breaking Dawn isn't as good as the rest of the books???

Oh, I will finally be able to read Breaking Dawn in a year! It comes out in Spring 2010, there was an add including the cover of Breaking Dawn with the dutch title in Eclipse.

[emma23]

It's probably because I didn't hate Jacob much in New moon... it was nice reading him as a friend like the movie theater bit with Bella/Jacob/Mike is funny. But it was eclipse that made me hate him, because he just became so arrogant, and horrible to anyone but Bella.

And with New moon its the whole ending from Volterra onwards that makes me love it, because its a lovely reunion and then the awesome volturi, and then Bella's epiphany realising that Edward has always loved her... its like the end part of New moon is my fave part out of the whole series and the part I have re-read the most.

New moon really makes you feel that Bella really loves Edward whereas Eclipse doesn't so much, only the very end. Seeing as shes so reluctant to marry him and then falls in love with Jacob

I still really do love Eclipse as well though! When I first read it I liked it a lot more then New moon.. its just as I re-read them a few times I just liked New moon more. Its like the few good parts in it makes it an amazing book for me. But the two books are close, they could almost be a joint second fave

Yeah I didnt like Breaking dawn... only book 1 out of it (its divided into three, with different POV's) even though it has some really great parts, the main storyline in it is just bad and kind of disturbing at one point. Although, A lot of people do still really like it
And I kind of did the first time, because I kept thinking 'aww' but now I just wish it had a better ending

[ Meg]

See, I still like Breaking Dawn, it's one of my favorites! I don't remember everything from the books, it's been a while since I read them. I need to re-read them again so I can respond here.

[~ ♥ Mariska ♥ ~]

haha, that gives me hope for the last book!